Skip to content
FAITH. LIBERTY. TRUTH. READ THE REVOLUTION WEAR THE REVOLUTION

BLACK MARKET CATTLE COMPANY // 90157

The Conversation Kit

Someone is going to ask you about your shirt. It happens in the feed store, the school pickup line, the gym, the airport. Usually it is not an argument. Usually it is a question — and the person asking is already curious, or they would have said nothing at all.

This is what to say.


THREE RULES BEFORE YOU OPEN YOUR MOUTH

1. You are not trying to win. The person in front of you is rarely the one who changes. The people quietly listening are. Talk to them.

2. Stay short and stay calm. One clear sentence does more work than five heated ones. Heat makes people defend their position. Clarity makes them examine it.

3. Leave a question, not a lecture. You are not trying to hand someone a finished worldview in a parking lot. You are trying to leave a splinter they cannot quite get out.


THE NINE QUESTIONS

“So you’re against the government?”

Say this: I am against the idea that one group of people has the right to force everyone else. Strip away the flag and the ceremony and look at what is actually being said: pay us, obey us, and do not ask questions. If anybody else ran that arrangement we would know exactly what to call it.

READ THE REVOLUTION: Government Is A Mafia

WATCH IT ANSWERED: Mike, live on The Black Market Report (at 34:14)

“Okay, but who is going to build the roads?”

Say this: Private industry built the roads, the telegraph, the telephone, electric light and the automobile itself before there was ever a permanent federal income tax. The question was never whether roads get built. The question is whether it is right to take a person’s labor to build them.

READ THE REVOLUTION: Yes, You Can Have Your Roads and Your Tax Money, Too

“Taxes are just the price of a civilized society.”

Say this: If it were a price I could decline it. Anything taken under threat is not a price. And the income tax is a specific claim on top of that — it says the product of your work belongs to somebody else before it belongs to you.

READ THE REVOLUTION: Income Tax Is Bondage  //  There Is No Such Thing As A Fair Tax

“Doesn’t the Bible say render unto Caesar?”

Say this: It says render to Caesar what is Caesar’s and to God what is God’s — and it never tells you which things are which. That is the actual question, and it is the one the quote is usually used to avoid. If God made the earth and everything in it, what is left on Caesar’s side?

READ THE REVOLUTION: Render Unto Caesar: Government, Property, and Taxation

WATCH IT ANSWERED: Mike, live on The Black Market Report (at 50:01)

“Without laws people would just do whatever they want.”

Say this: Almost everything you are picturing already has a victim, and people understood it was wrong long before any legislature voted on it. The trouble is the enormous body of law where nobody is harmed at all — and that is what fills the cages.

READ THE REVOLUTION: No victim, no crime

WATCH IT ANSWERED: Mike, live on The Black Market Report (at 1:09:16)

“That’s just a conspiracy theory.”

Say this: Some of them are, and you should be careful, because some get invented specifically to make everyone asking questions look ridiculous. But that phrase has also become a way to end a conversation instead of having one. Ask what is actually documented and go from there.

READ THE REVOLUTION: Conspiracy Theories: A Collection

“So what am I supposed to do, not vote?”

Say this: Use the power you actually have. If you are ever seated on a jury you can refuse to convict a person under a law you believe is unjust. That is not a loophole and it is not new. It is older than the country.

READ THE REVOLUTION: Ask Me About Jury Nullification

WATCH IT ANSWERED: Mike, live on The Black Market Report (at 2:57)

“Why does a cattle company sell T-shirts?”

Say this: Because the shirt is how the conversation starts and the writing is what carries it. The designs put the idea in public. The essays give you the argument to back it up. It is one project, not two.

READ THE REVOLUTION: Why I Built Black Market Cattle Company  //  Black Market Cattle Company Is Bigger Than Beef

“So you’re a Republican? A Libertarian?”

Say this: Neither. This is not a team. It is one standard applied the same way every time: do not use force against peaceful people, including when the people holding the force happen to agree with you.

READ THE REVOLUTION: Why I Left the Libertarian Party and the Mises Caucus

WATCH IT ANSWERED: Mike, live on The Black Market Report (at 1:15:46)


IF YOU ONLY REMEMBER ONE LINE

Good ideas don’t require force.

It fits on a shirt because it is the whole argument. If an idea is genuinely good it can be explained, defended and chosen. It does not need a threat behind it. Almost every conversation on this list ends up back there.

READ THE REVOLUTION: Good Ideas Don’t Require Force


KEEP GOING