Skip to content
FAITH. LIBERTY. TRUTH. READ THE REVOLUTION WEAR THE REVOLUTION
THE BLACK MARKET REPORT 11.19.2026

Natural Rights, Statism, Communism and All the Isms

Mike Shaner on his Wednesday evening Black Market Report live, November 18, 2026: Natural Rights, Statism, Communism and All the Isms

If I think you’re arguing with me in good faith, I’ll argue with you. Even if I think you’re in bad faith, but I think you’re smart, then I don’t think you’re going to be arguing in bad faith, because you’re going to believe your argument. You’re going to be able to give it to me intelligently. So I love it. I love debating people who disagree with me, who can give a rational and honest debate, because honestly, every position I had, I evolved to get here through debate. That’s how I learned, by debating with someone else, especially when someone has an argument that I can’t overcome, because I don’t like losing, and I don’t like cheating. So I’ll find an honest way to overcome it if I can, or if I cannot, then I’ll change my position, which I think any intelligent person will do.

That’s how I went from being a Democrat to a Republican to a libertarian to a voluntaryist. I was a Democrat because I was told, and this was a very different time, this was pre-Clinton through Clinton, that Democrats believed in civil liberties, individual rights, and they were anti-war. And then I found out none of that was true. None of it. They believed in individual rights as long as you said the things that they wanted you to say. They protected the speech that they wanted to hear. If it was speech that offended but was conversational and worth having, they didn’t like that. And if you wanted to keep your money or your property, they didn’t believe in that type of individual liberty. So I was like, well, Republicans say they believe in small government, right? Limited government. So, okay, I’ll be a Republican. And they don’t believe in small government. They believe in real big government.

It turned out that if you took a puzzle and pulled it apart, you would have Democrats on this side and Republicans on this side, and when you put them together, you have government. They claim to believe in completely separate things, but it’s like a one-size-fits-all. You have to believe everything the Republicans believe over here, even though a lot of the things they believe contradict what you believe. In order to get what you believe from the Democrats, you have to accept all these other things that you don’t believe. They connect together, and they’re illogical things that go together.

Then I found Ron Paul, and my whole world changed. I became a libertarian, and in my heart I was an anarchist. But I could not reconcile protecting those rights with a stateless society, and it took me years and years to be able to do that. I don’t even use the term anarchist. I am a voluntaryist. I believe in an opt-in society. And the difference between me and a communist is, in my ideal world, in my utopia, you can be a communist. But in a communist world, you can’t be a voluntaryist. You can’t opt out. That’s the big deal.

I believe in communism as an opt-in ideology. I believe it can even work as an opt-in ideology, meaning you buy your hundred acres, whatever it is, and you set it up as a co-op. You all live there. You call it your little town. Everybody shares the wealth. If you want to live there, you sign the agreement that you’re going to do that. I don’t believe anything works on a mass scale. But as long as that is the property of your commune, that you’ve all voluntarily entered into and can leave at any time, I am all for that. I don’t want to live in it. I would rather live over in voluntary town, where I can trade with you freely and I can sell my labor for a rate that I think my labor is worth, instead of the community telling me what my labor is worth. I believe my town will be more prosperous, but I’m willing to have those competing towns, and I’m willing to not go into your town and tell you how to change. The communists don’t want to extend me that same right.

I got to this point by debating. I took the wrong side for so long. And then I came to realize that the thing I was arguing would happen without a state is the existence of a state. What we live in is the thing that everybody fears. Everybody fears that if you take the state out of the system, you will get to a place where warmongers run, where warlords run society, and we have that. Look at the Epstein class that we live in, the world that we live in. Everything you’re afraid of is there. So worst case scenario, we get back to status quo.

If rights are only granted by force or by the state, then rights can never be violated. There’s no violation of rights, because it doesn’t exist. It’s granted to you by them. So if they take it away, it’s theirs. They can’t violate your rights. Now, if rights are granted to you by nature, which I believe they are, they’re evident of your nature. Because I’m a Christian, I believe rights were granted to me by God. If you are an atheist and you don’t believe that rights are granted by God, then rights are granted to you by nature. They come just as a matter of being a human being.

People like to use that as a gotcha. They say, “Oh, you’re trying to say I don’t have a right to water.” No, you don’t have a right to water, because you can’t just have water. You do have a right to pursue water. If I go out with my own labor and I dig a well on my own property, that’s mine. I know my Christianity says I should share it, but being moral and talking specifically about rights are two different things. I do believe humans should have clean drinking water. In fact, I believe it’s my responsibility as a Christian to make sure that people have access to clean drinking water. My responsibility, though, not your responsibility.

If something is granted, it’s not a right. Right means it’s inherent upon you. If something is inherent, it can’t be revoked. If it’s a right, it can’t be revoked. It can only be infringed. The difference between revocation and infringement is important, hugely important. You can’t ever lose a right. No one can take away your right. People who say, “I have a constitutional right”: no, you have a constitutionally protected right. What that means is that the founders put in the Constitution a protection against government from violating that right. It did not enshrine you with a right. If you deify the founders, if you deify that document, you’re stepping outside of what is natural and putting that thing or those people in place of God.

I have the right to say anything I want to say. I was born with the right, and I understand language, and I can naturally say it, no matter how offensive or hateful or horrible or gross or disgusting it may be. And if you and I are occupying the same space and I’m saying things that you don’t want to hear, that you find offensive, you have every right to leave, but you have no right to shut me up, because that would require you imposing force upon me where I’m not harming you. You may not like my words, but my words are not physically hurting you. They’re not stealing your property. They’re not trespassing upon you. You just don’t like them.

Libertarians like to say taxation is theft, but it’s worse than theft. It’s pure slavery. Here’s the thing. I own myself. That is the one thing in this world I own, for sure. Did you know that even chattel slavery owners, plantation owners, would allow the plantation slaves to raise gardens, sell things at market, keep a portion of the money? Even chattel slaves were allowed to keep a portion of their own income. So people get offended when I compare income taxation to slavery. But if I own myself, then I own the fruits that I produce. I own the sweat from my brow. If you want a ditch dug, and I dig a ditch, and you pay me $100, and the government says you have to give me $30, the government is claiming it owns 30% of what I produce. At that point, it’s saying it owns a portion of me. And if I don’t give it to them, they will take it with the threat of a cage.

If something is worth paying for, nobody has to make you. You pay for internet. You pay for your cell phone. If something’s worth doing, force isn’t needed. If there’s a market for something, it will be paid for. I come from a place where there’s a volunteer fire department. I’ve never actually lived anywhere where there was a municipal-level fire department. And I cut them a check every year. Every year they send me a postcard: “Hey, your fire dues are ready.” And I send it to them. Never think twice about it, because it’s a voluntary transaction, and I like having a fire department.

What we used to say when we were kids was, communism is good in theory, but it can never work in practicality. It ain’t good in theory. It’s not a good theory. The theory of communism is that you belong to the society, you belong to the collective, you belong to the greater good. There is no greater good than individual liberty. I believe that fostering individual liberty is the most prosperous way for society to exist. I don’t belong to a collective. I believe in humanity. I believe I will sacrifice for the good of my community, for the good of humanity, out of my own free will. And if you don’t want to, I believe you shouldn’t. But I’m not obligated to do that. That’s not selfishness either. I was given this life, this existence. Either you can say by nature; I say by God.


From Mike Shaner’s Wednesday evening Black Market Report live, November 18, 2026. Watch it here, or free on Substack.

Chapters

00:00 Natural rights, statism, communism and all the isms
00:26 My most popular work
01:25 The reel about income tax and slavery
02:36 A comment on that reel
02:47 When I block people
03:41 Bitcoin’s below 62,000
04:39 Argue with me in good faith
05:03 Every position I hold came from debate
05:42 Who will build the roads?
06:37 How insurance took over medicine
06:58 Wage controls
08:13 Health insurance as a perk
09:02 Careful what you wish for
09:45 Democrat, Republican, libertarian, voluntaryist
10:52 Why I was a Democrat
11:40 Then a Republican
11:58 Alabama loves government
12:15 Vote no to gambling in Alabama
13:46 Two pieces of one puzzle
14:29 Death penalty and abortion
15:27 Then I found Ron Paul
16:20 Anarchists who are communists
16:37 In my utopia, you can be a communist
17:10 Communism as an opt-in ideology
18:45 What everybody fears already exists
19:27 What are rights?
20:22 Are rights granted by force?
20:55 Then rights could never be violated
21:22 Rights from nature, or from God
22:06 What you’re born with
22:59 Do you have a right to water?
24:27 What good is a right you can’t enforce?
25:41 Who argues against natural rights
26:12 Infringed, never revoked
26:35 You don’t have a Second Amendment right
27:33 Don’t deify the founders
28:17 The right to say anything
29:51 On your property, your rules
30:39 No right to bring a gun onto my property
32:04 January 6 versus BLM
32:48 Discrimination against the poor
35:26 Where the communists come in
36:27 The state protects giant corporations
37:26 We didn’t just wake up one day
38:12 Income tax is slavery
38:45 Even slaves kept part of their income
39:24 The government owns 30% of you
40:03 Shut up and pay your taxes
40:45 Forced to fund what I believe is evil
42:14 An offense to God
43:51 If it’s worth paying for, nobody has to make you
44:41 My volunteer fire department
45:31 Government never provided anything
45:47 Communism isn’t good in theory
46:40 I don’t belong to a collective
47:23 I don’t owe my years to anyone
48:36 No communism without a state
48:51 Somebody’s getting rich
49:42 Republicans who believe in communism
50:21 Statism needs communism
51:38 Like professional wrestlers
52:14 Lysander Spooner beat the post office
53:01 My toddler woke up